| dScryb | ENnies | Best Online Content; Silver | 2021 |
| Mordenkainen's Tome of Foes | Origins | Best Roleplaying Game Supplement | 2019 |
| Xanathar's Guide to Everything | Golden Geek | RPG Best Artwork and Presentation | 2017 |
| Tales from the Yawning Portal | ENnies | Judges' Spotlight Winner | 2017 |
| Out of the Abyss | ENnies | Judges' Spotlight Winner | 2016 |
| Monster Manual | Origins | Best Roleplaying Game | 2015 |
| Player's Handbook | Origins | Best Roleplaying Game Supplement | 2015 |
| Player's Handbook | ENnies | Product of the Year; Gold | 2015 |
| Player's Handbook | ENnies | Best Writing; Silver | 2015 |
| Dungeon Master's Guide | ENnies | Best Supplement; Gold | 2015 |
| Player's Handbook | ENnies | Best Rules; Gold | 2015 |
| Monster Manual | ENnies | Best Monster or Adversary; Gold | 2015 |
| Player's Handbook | ENnies | Best Game; Gold | 2015 |
| Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition | Golden Geek | Game of the Year | 2014 |
| Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition Starter Set | Golden Geek | Best Supplement | 2014 |
| Lords of Waterdeep: Scoundrels of Skullport | Dice Tower Awards | Best Expansion | 2014 |
| Lords of Waterdeep iOS | BoardGameGeek.com | Reader's Choice Game of the Year | 2014 |
| Lords of Waterdeep | Origins | Best Board Game | 2013 |
| Lords of Waterdeep: Scoundrels of Skullport | Golden Geek | Best Board Game Expansion | 2013 |
| Lords of Waterdeep | Guldbrikken | Special Jury Prize Winner | 2012 |
| Lords of Waterdeep | ENnies | Best RPG Related Product | 2012 |
| Monster Vault | ENnies | Best Monster or Adversary; Silver | 2011 |
| Dungeons & Dragons Miniatures | ENnies | Best Minis; Gold | 2010 |
| Player's Handbook 3 | ENnies | Best Supplement; Silver | 2010 |
| Player's Handbook | ENnies | Best Rules; Gold | 2009 |
| Monster Manual | ENnies | Best Monster or Adversary; Gold | 2009 |
| Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition | ENnies | Product of the Year, Best Game; Gold | 2009 |
| D&D Icons: Legend of Drizzt | ENnies | Best Minis; Gold | 2008 |
| D&D Icons: Colossal Red Dragon | Origins | Best Minatures Line | 2006 |
| Dragon Compendium, Vol 1 | ENnies | Best Supplement; Gold | 2006 |
| Advanced Bestiary | Monte Cook Presents | Excellence | 2005 |
| Dragon Magazine | Origins | Best Periodical | 2003 |
| Unlimited Adventures | SSI | Grand Prize (Best Overall Dungeon Design) | 1994 |